Americans Joke About Trump Adopting Canada as the 51st State
December 05, 2024Key Takeaways
- Americans are enjoying Trump’s joke about making Canada the 51st state if his tariff plan destroys their economy.
- While most people accept and lean into the joke, some take a more serious tone, critiquing Trump, his tariff plan, and the implications of the comment.
- Republicans tend to be endeared to Trump by his humorous style, while liberals complain that he is unserious and damaging America’s global image.
Our Methodology
Demographics
All Voters
Sample Size
15,000
Geographical Breakdown
National
Time Period
2 Days
MIG Reports leverages EyesOver technology, employing Advanced AI for precise analysis. This ensures unparalleled precision, setting a new standard. Find out more about the unique data pull for this article.
Donald Trump’s comment to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau that Canada could become the 51st state has caused raucous reactions online. Joking about what might happen if his tariff plan destroys Canada’s economy, Trump suggested the U.S. would take Canada under its wing as a state and Trudeau could become the governor.
Overall reactions accept Trump’s joke for what it is, piling on with memes about Canada in both serious commentary and internet hilarity. Trump himself even added fuel to the fire by posting an AI image of himself with a Canadian flag.
In for the Lolz, Out for Real
MIG Reports data shows:
- 66% of American reactions lean into the joke, seeing it as characteristic of Trump’s rhetorical style and memetic power. Many also view it as an opportunity to roast Canadians.
- 34% take a more serious tone of skepticism or concern, viewing the comment through a lens of nationalism, U.S.-Canada relations, and cultural identity.
- Around 43% of the discussion comes from Canadians who react similarly with mixed humor and real fears of “Americanization” and cultural encroachment.
While Americans mostly take a sarcastic and joking tone, there are some giving honest reactions to the possibility, including advocating for Canada as a territory rather than a state, and providing cultural critiques of progressive ideology in the Great White North.
I’m in favor of annexing Canada, but only as a territory, not as state. We don’t need them voting.
— Sarah 🥨 (@cosmopterix) December 3, 2024
What Americans Are Saying
Jokes
Those approaching Trump’s comment with humor appreciate his ability to engage audiences with bold and unconventional rhetoric. They also demonstrate an eagerness to add a classic flavor of American mockery toward Canadians, holding Trudeau as symbolic of feminized culture and a less powerful nation.
Trump Announces Plan To Annex Canada And Rename It ‘Gay North Dakota’ https://t.co/tbuYeKWVyJ pic.twitter.com/5kaEV0hYF4
— The Babylon Bee (@TheBabylonBee) December 4, 2024
Jokes and memes often include:
- The absurdity of merging two culturally distinct nations.
- Trump’s penchant for using humor to deflect or lighten serious topics.
- Trudeau’s image in America as everything wrong with progressive governance.
- Insinuations of America’s “older sibling” ethos regarding Canada.
Dear Canada-
— Steve 🇺🇸 (@SteveLovesAmmo) December 3, 2024
If you want to join the United States, we have a few rules.
1. The leaf flag must go.
2. Firearm possession must go up by 500% per household.
3. Justin Trudeau must be exiled to Cuba to be with his ancestry.
4. You will be referred to as snow Mexicans.
Sounds like…
Criticism
Those who take a more critical stance toward Trump’s comment, highlight:
- Concerns about nationalism and cultural dilution.
- Apprehension over the impact of such rhetoric on U.S.-Canada relations and global perceptions of American governance.
These reactions are more pronounced among Democrats and Independents, who view Trump’s humor as undermining the seriousness of international relations.
Economic Anxiety
Canada is the largest trading partner for 34 of 50 U.S. states, with key industries like agriculture and manufacturing deeply intertwined across borders. This causes many Americans to use the comment as a jumping off point to discuss economic and trade concerns:
- Fear of rising costs and disrupted supply chains due to Trump’s proposed tariffs.
- Comparisons to historical policies like the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act cause anxiety about economic fallout.
Canadian Reactions
While there is less discussion among Canadians, like Americans, they have mixed reactions. Many accept the humor of the comment, but some have serious objections.
- Many dismiss the joke as typical of Trump's bombastic style.
- Those laughing about it find amusement in the idea of trying to merge Canadian and American culture and politics.
- Those expressing fears talk about the erosion of Canadian identity and values.
- They worry about an “Americanization” of their culture and governance.
- Some worry about economic sovereignty and retaliation, taking a cautious approach to U.S.-Canada relations.
Predictive Analysis
This discourse, while unlikely to have long-term political consequences, reveals important voter dynamics:
- For Republicans, humor will continue to reinforce Trump’s appeal, demonstrating his ability to gain attention and influence using unconventional rhetoric.
- Democrats will likely use the remark to amplify critiques of Trump’s governance style, further galvanizing opposition.
- Independents may have mixed reactions as many are frustrated with Trump’s persona, while feeling torn about the effectiveness of his policies.
- For Canadians, the discussion reinforces the importance of asserting cultural and economic independence, particularly in the face of U.S. dominance.