Trump’s Closing Argument: “How do you like my garbage truck?”
November 01, 2024Key Takeaways
- Biden and Trump steal Harris’s thunder at The Ellipse with viral “garbage” memes, following days of media outrage over Puerto Rico.
- A viral clip of Biden calling Trump supporters garbage dominates discussion, gaining 70% of the conversation compared to 30% around Harris’s rally.
- Trump became the symbol of counter-messaging by arriving for his Green Bay rally wearing an orange vest and riding in a garbage truck.
Our Methodology
Demographics
All Voters
Sample Size
26,000
Geographical Breakdown
National
Time Period
2 Days
MIG Reports leverages EyesOver technology, employing Advanced AI for precise analysis. This ensures unparalleled precision, setting a new standard. Find out more about the unique data pull for this article.
After multiple days of mainstream media coverage of Tony Hinchcliffe’s Puerto Rico joke at Trump’s MSG rally, Joe Biden stole the news cycle by calling Trump supporters “garbage.” This led to Trump’s meme-like arrival in Green Bay on a garbage truck. All this dramatic and joke-driven controversy overshadowed Kamala Harris’s major rally speech at the Ellipse in D.C.
Sometimes the Democrat elite tell us what they really think of us. Hillary Clinton thinks we are “deplorables”. Joe Biden thinks we are “garbage.” Kamala Harris thinks we are so stupid as to believe her lies.
— Tulsi Gabbard 🌺 (@TulsiGabbard) October 30, 2024
We deserve better. Vote Trump pic.twitter.com/cwEBnGSbLj
Voter reactions show how each candidate’s strategic choices and surrogate impact are shaping the final days of the campaign.
- Prior to Joe Biden’s comment, Harris was leading Trump in national sentiment as news coverage slammed the MSG rally.
- After Biden’s “garbage” comment and Trump’s subsequent garbage truck stunt, public sentiment in swing states and nationally swung in Trump’s favor.
- In the national race, Trump maintains a support lead with 53% support to Harris’s 44%.
Harris at the Ellipse vs. Biden’s “Garbage”
Closing Arguments
Kamala Harris’s Ellipse rally drew an impressive crowd, reportedly reaching 75,000 attendees—a notable turnout for any candidate. Her message centered on anti-Trump rhetoric, January 6, calls for unity, and even, again cribbing from Trump, claims that a Harris administration would implement deportations for illegal immigrants.
Vice Pres. Harris addresses voters from the Ellipse, where then-Pres. Donald Trump gave Jan. 6 speech.
— ABC News Politics (@ABCPolitics) October 29, 2024
“He is the person who stood at this very spot nearly four years ago and sent an armed mob to the United States Capitol." https://t.co/ruQEQkjaUQ pic.twitter.com/MwPeAE9Ubb
The speech resonated with her base, eliciting positive responses. However, the message alone fell flat with most Americans, including the pro-Palestine segment of Democratic voters.
Unfortunately, the content alone was not the downfall of Harris’s closing argument for presidential office. In the midst of her rally, Joe Biden was on camera making comments that swiftly took over the news cycle.
Biden’s “Garbage” Comment
Biden’s comment calling Trump supporters “garbage” flooded online conversation and news coverage. The episode drew outrage among conservatives who viewed it as another example of disdain from Democratic elites, causing team Biden to issue a clarification. The Washington Post helped with damage control.
Earlier today I referred to the hateful rhetoric about Puerto Rico spewed by Trump's supporter at his Madison Square Garden rally as garbage—which is the only word I can think of to describe it. His demonization of Latinos is unconscionable. That's all I meant to say. The…
— Joe Biden (@JoeBiden) October 30, 2024
However, the controversy escalated when mainstream media and even the White House transcript began to spin the remark, claiming he wasn't referring to all Trump supporters. Discussion volumes around Biden vastly overshadowed Harris’s rally, adding fuel to the fire for those decrying Democrats over hypocrisy.
BREAKING: Rep @EliseStefanik sent a scorching letter to the White House Counsel demanding they correctly quote Biden's "garbage" comment after the official WH transcript EDITED it to cover for Biden.
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) October 30, 2024
They may have BROKEN THE LAW.
The WH is trying to rewrite history. This is… pic.twitter.com/EZEMTTkv0K
Losing the Spotlight
MIG Reports data shows 70% of conversations following the incident focused on Biden’s remark compared to only 30% discussing Harris’s speech and rally.
Conservatives
- Trump supporters are quick to point out the hypocrisy of Democrats and the media.
- They say those who claimed to be scandalized by a Puerto Rico joke were too quick to dismiss Biden’s comment.
- Many MAGA voters also embrace the label, calling for Trump to make use of the comment by working a garbage route.
Independent Discontent
- Moderates and Independents largely voice disappointment in Biden’s tone.
- They say it’s yet another instance of divisive rhetoric in politics, which contradicts Harris’s attempt at a unity message.
- Independents are disillusioned with the rhetoric on both sides of the aisle, but many recognize the incongruence of media coverage.
Trump’s Garbageman Meme
Adding insult to injury for Harris, who lost the news cycle, Trump arrived at his Green Bay rally wearing a reflective orange vest and riding a garbage truck. Social media erupted with commentary, making viral photos and clips of Trump into memes and jokes at the expense of Biden and Harris.
PRESIDENT TRUMP: "How do you like my garbage truck? This truck is in honor of Kamala and Joe Biden." pic.twitter.com/7UwMZ8syvx
— Trump War Room (@TrumpWarRoom) October 30, 2024
Trump’s tongue-in-cheek and unapologetic style energizes his base. Embracing the garbage meme, Trump appeals to everyday, working-class Americans as refreshingly down-to-earth. He also took the time to sincerely assure Americans that they are not garbage.
President Trump is about to get off Trump Force One…and head over to the MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN Garbage Truck here in Wisconsin… pic.twitter.com/XpqvRFqgJv
— Dan Scavino Jr.🇺🇸🦅 (@DanScavino) October 30, 2024
Internal Biden-Harris Conflict?
The Biden-Harris relationship has also become a focal point of discussion across voter groups, with each side interpreting this dynamic differently. Many speculate that, behind closed doors, Joe Biden and Kamala Harris have a rocky relationship where, intentionally or inadvertently, Biden ends up damaging her with his public comments.
Even among those who do not believe there is animosity between the two, most agree that Biden is not helping Harris on the campaign trail. This was once again demonstrated by confusion and disgust at images of Biden biting babies at the White House Halloween Party.
President Trump is mingling with garbage men at his rally in Wisconsin.
— Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) October 31, 2024
Meanwhile, Joe Biden is literally BITING BABIES at the White House Halloween Party.
WTF IS THIS TIMELINE? pic.twitter.com/wYIzsDjxDt
Republican Criticism
- GOP voters see Harris as complicit in Biden’s failures, viewing her as an ineffective extension of his administration.
- Many Republicans speculate about bad blood between the two, suggesting Biden may be intentionally undermining her.
Unenthusiastic Democrats
- While Democrats acknowledge Harris’s historic role, there is significant tension within the party.
- The base voices frustration over Harris's ineffectiveness both as VP and on the campaign trail.
- There are also questions about the division she causes among different groups like Muslims and black men.
Independent Ambivalence
- For Independents, Harris’s visibility compared to Biden raises questions about leadership within the administration.
- Many express sentiments suggesting Americans have “forgotten that Biden is president.”
- This group wants an action-oriented administration, and the perceived lack of coordination among Democrats is causing some to reconsider their support.