Lester Holt’s NBC News interview with Joe Biden gave the American public more fodder to criticize the performance and abilities of the President. The conversation generated conversations about taxation, economic policies, national security, and public trust. Analysis of the discourse reveals overarching themes and prevailing sentiments of disappointment and disillusionment with Joe Biden as the sitting president.

HOLT: "If you were to have, continue to run and be officially nominated, what happens if you have another episode like we saw during the debate?"

BIDEN: "What happenuvanuh?"

HOLT: "Yeah, what happens if you have another performance on that par, on that level?"

BIDEN: "I don't… pic.twitter.com/2YHmWBfokq

— Vince Coglianese (@VinceCoglianese) July 16, 2024

Economics, Economics, Economics

One of the most consistent topics Americans focus on is Biden’s tax policies, particularly his plans to repeal Trump-era tax cuts. Critics vehemently argue this will lead to increased taxes for most Americans. They also say this move will cement Trump as the champion of tax reduction and economic prosperity.

This narrative is potent among anyone who felt positively about their economic prospects and the market climate under Trump. Biden supporters counter by emphasizing his tax policies target only the very wealthy. They say this will correct economic disparities and bolster social programs.

Economic issues that concern Americans extend beyond taxation. People also worry about inflation and job security. Biden critics blame his administration for rising inflation, often called a hidden tax, saying it disproportionately affects the middle and lower classes. Many argue economic conditions were more favorable under Trump, highlighting personal anecdotes of better financial stability during his tenure.

Biden advocates, however, point out reports that say overall unemployment has decreased. They credit Biden’s policies for bringing jobs and stability back after COVID. This economic dialogue is significant in shaping the perceptions of undecided voters who prioritize financial stability and employment prospects.

However, there are serious questions about whether Americans believe the jobs and economy narrative Biden’s administration is pushing. Many express skepticism over constantly revised job reports and the realities of their own situations. Some voters feel Biden’s economic and job offerings are a last-ditch effort to shore up votes before November.

Critics point to the fact that most of Biden’s alleged job growth stems from federal jobs. In 2023, nearly 25% of all job gains in the U.S. job market were attributed to government positions. This highlights a significant dependence on public sector employment to support economic growth. Additionally, the government's household survey indicates, as of May 2024, there are only 971,000 more U.S.-born Americans employed compared to May 2019, before COVID. Whereas, the number of employed immigrants has risen by 3.2 million.

Open Borders, A Conversation Starter

National security and public safety are recurrent themes, fueled by discussions of border policies and recent high-profile criminal events. Biden detractors blame his administration for exacerbated security risks, citing open borders and increased crime rates. People contrast this with the promise of stricter, more effective security measures under Trump. This rhetoric aims to persuade voters who prioritize safety and border control to lean away from Biden.

Public trust issues also dominate the conversation around Biden’s recent interviews. Misinformation and distrust of politicians and the political system are rampant, with accusations from both sides. Biden's critics paint him as deceitful and out of touch, questioning his credibility and often quipping about conspiracies regarding past political misdeeds and current policies.

Biden supporters emphasize the need to hold on to democratic values and counter the rhetoric of Trump, which they believe is a threat to democracy itself. This polarized view challenges undecided voters to navigate through a cacophony of deeply contentious narratives.

How Americans Feel about Joe Biden

Sentiment trends confirm political divides. There is palpable frustration and anger among Biden’s critics, who insist he now clearly is incapable of governing. Their language is often heated with a sense of urgency to “save” the country from poor policies and a puppet presidency. Biden supporters are defensive. They take a proactive stance urging for continued support and engagement through voting to ensure a progressive trajectory.

For undecided and Independent voters, reactions suggest a complex landscape. Those dissatisfied with current economic conditions, swayed by the argument of high inflation and ineffective economic strategies, might be leaning away from Biden. However, voters who value democratic stability and view Trump as a destabilizing force might find solace in Biden's promises, despite economic concerns.

Ultimately, Biden's Lester Holt interview appears to have deepened existing political divides, with strong reactions on both sides. Biden’s base continues to defend him, resigning themselves to vote for him—if only to preserve the Party’s agenda. However, this simultaneously provides fodder for his critics who view supporting a clearly incapacitated president as equally threatening to the country.

For undecided and Independent voters, their sway might hinge on personal economic experiences and perceptions of national security rather than the interview alone. They may need more tangible evidence of policy impacts leading up to the elections.