Having a Menty B: America’s Growing Mental Health Crisis
December 01, 2024Key Takeaways
- Most Americans agree that mental health struggles have become a crisis for the nation but disagree about causes and solutions.
- Younger generations prioritize access to mental health care and destigmatizing struggles, while older generations fear isolation and depression.
- Progressives typically want interventions, funding, and access for minorities, while conservatives emphasize personal choices and combating wokeism.
Our Methodology
Demographics
All Voters
Sample Size
8,600
Geographical Breakdown
National
Time Period
7 Days
MIG Reports leverages EyesOver technology, employing Advanced AI for precise analysis. This ensures unparalleled precision, setting a new standard. Find out more about the unique data pull for this article.
Many Americans believe mental health has reached a crisis level in recent years. Across the political spectrum, voters recognize the widespread and serious nature of mental health struggles is impacting society.
Economic stress, political division, and cultural upheaval have all contributed and, for many, resolving the mental health crisis has become a national priority. Americans want action, and their conversations reflect the urgency. Rising rates of untreated mental health issues also contribute to crime, homelessness, drug abuse, and societal discord.
What Americans are Saying
MIG Reports data shows:
Millennials and Gen Z
- Prioritize access to care and services like telehealth.
- Place a high priority on destigmatization, saying people should feel comfortable discussing and dealing with their issues.
- Advocate for making mental health care as accessible as physical care through insurance coverage.
Gen X
- Tie the crisis to job instability, economic stress, and societal decay.
- Support early interventions in schools and robust community support systems.
Boomers
- Highlight caregiving stress and the need for mental health programs targeting isolation and depression.
- Call for federal funding to alleviate these burdens.
Economic Factors
Economic instability is one of the most significant contributors to mental health concerns. Inflation, rising unemployment, and stagnant wages weigh heavily on struggling Americans. People discuss:
- Expanded funding for affordable mental health services.
- Community-driven initiatives to provide support for those unable to access traditional care.
- Recognition that economic stability directly correlates with improved mental well-being.
The Role of Politics
The political divide also shapes voter discourse.
NEW: Liberals hold a ‘Primal Scream’ event at Lake Michigan to get their frustrations out of their system after the election.
— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) November 27, 2024
Some in the group were seen jumping in the water after releasing their primal scream.
The group was apparently trolled by a Trump supporter waving a… pic.twitter.com/7sLy4AfQgy
Progressives
- Want systemic changes to remedy socioeconomic inequities, saying improving people’s economic outlook will improve their mental health.
- Push for government-led initiatives to provide care to marginalized communities.
- Believe America’s history, racism, misogyny, and inequality worsen mental health.
Conservatives
- Emphasize personal responsibility, traditional values, and skepticism toward government overreach.
- Blame "woke culture" for promoting victimhood over resilience, contributing to anxiety, depression, and suicide.
- Suggest over-prescribing medication and excess talk therapy have worsened rather than remedied mental health issues.
Independents
- Seek bipartisan solutions, balancing systemic reforms with personal accountability.
While political perspectives differ, a common thread unites them—frustration with failed solutions. Voters increasingly view mental health as a nonpartisan issue that demands urgent attention.
Cultural and Ideological Barriers
Cultural factors further complicate the mental health debate:
Stigma Persists
- Despite growing awareness, many voters cite stigma as a barrier to seeking help.
- Many say older generations are particularly reluctant to engage in conversations about mental health.
Polarizing Narratives
- Critiques of identity politics and "woke" culture dominate conservative discourse.
- This group says progressive ideologies exacerbate mental health issues by fostering division and victimhood.
- They point to reactions from progressives following the election, with many examples of people screaming or crying on camera, lamenting Trump’s win.
- Many also say there has been a societal shift away from resilience, with younger generations especially prone to emotional sheltering.
Potential Paths Forward
There is significant disagreement politically and ideologically about how to solve mental health issues in America. While most agree the problem is worsening and that social media is a contributing factor, there is no consensus on how to improve the situation.
While progressives tend to advocate for political or healthcare solutions, conservatives lean more toward cultural and individual solutions. Like most areas in American life, divisions create divergent paths forward.