What Does “Democracy” Mean to American Voters?
March 07, 2025.png)
Key Takeaways
- Americans use “democracy” in different conversations, suggesting political sides define what it means differently.
- Democrats often use democracy to advocate for stronger government protections and programs for vulnerable populations.
- Republicans often talk about democracy as important for checking political power and preventing the increase of government.
Our Methodology
Demographics
All Voters
Sample Size
124,000
Geographical Breakdown
National
Time Period
4 Days
MIG Reports leverages EyesOver technology, employing Advanced AI for precise analysis. This ensures unparalleled precision, setting a new standard. Find out more about the unique data pull for this article.
The way Americans use the word “democracy” and talk about its meaning suggests they no longer agree on what it means. This divide is not new, but it has deepened. In many online discussions, there is a partisan divide in how people view democracy and its import in American life.
- 70% of conversations on democracy focus on economic issues, particularly taxation and government spending.
- 85% of Democrats equate democracy with social welfare programs, arguing cuts to Medicaid, Social Security, and food assistance undermine its foundation.
- 75% of Republicans relate democracy to individual autonomy, where lower taxes and deregulation empower citizens.
- 60% of independent discussions are critical, they see both political parties as failures and demand greater accountability.
Two Americas, Two Democracies
The Progressive View
The progressive model of democracy is expansive. It absorbs social, economic, and cultural concerns under the banner of democratic protection. The ideal is a managed democracy where government intervention is a prerequisite for fairness.
Democrats frame democracy as a tool for redistribution and government intervention. In their discussions, social safety nets define democratic responsibility. The government’s role is to correct inequality, ensure access to healthcare, and protect marginalized groups from systemic oppression.
Their language reflects this focus. When discussing fiscal policy, Democrats describe Republican tax cuts as “attacks on democracy.” They say economic disparity is an existential threat to political stability.
Most Democratic responses in recent online discourse oppose tax cuts, citing their impact on wealth inequality. They call for aggressive state action—on corporate regulation, censorship of "misinformation," and expanded federal oversight—framing it as necessary, not authoritarian.
.png)
The Conservative View
Conservatives more often talk about democracy as preserving the rights of individuals against the creeping power of the state. They see it through the lens of individual sovereignty. In their framework, democracy thrives when government steps back.
Republicans see welfare as a mechanism of dependency that erodes civic responsibility. 75% emphasize tax cuts and deregulation as essential to preserving democracy, citing government overreach as its greatest threat.
Immigration policy follows the same pattern. While Democrats frame sanctuary cities as democratic commitments to inclusivity, Republicans argue an open-border approach dilutes national sovereignty and democratic self-determination. In conservative circles, democracy is national, not universal. The rule of law, the integrity of the voter base, and the ability of citizens—not noncitizens—to shape governance are non-negotiable.
The Independent Dilemma
Many who identify as independent voters discuss democracy not as a functioning system but rather an abstract concept used to justify partisan entrenchment.
Independents increasingly reject both parties’ interpretations of democracy. They voice skepticism toward government transparency and accountability. They see dysfunction, corruption, and an entrenched political class using “democracy” as a branding tool rather than a guiding principle.
They criticize Republicans for failing to follow through on limited government promises and view Democratic pushes for expanded state control as a power grab. They want bipartisan cooperation on economic and social issues, though there is little belief that either party will prioritize governance over electoral positioning.
.png)
Democracy as a Weapon
Because the use of “democracy” is often ideological, it has become a political weapon. Each side accuses the other of subverting democratic principles, but their accusations are rooted in fundamentally different understandings of what democracy entails.
- Democrats claim Republican tax cuts and budget reductions erode democracy by weakening government protections.
- Republicans argue Democratic policies threaten democracy by expanding bureaucratic control and suppressing the voices of voters.
- Independents increasingly believe both sides exploit “democracy” as a slogan while failing to protect any actual function of it.
Nowhere is this clearer than in the debate over speech and censorship. Democrats, prioritizing "misinformation control," frame content moderation as essential to preserving democracy. Republicans, prioritizing free speech, see these policies as authoritarian suppression. Each side sees itself as protecting democracy while accusing the other of undermining it.
Divides and Policy Battles
The fracture over democracy is not theoretical but plays out in every major policy debate.
Democracy and the Economy
Many frame the debate over taxation as a debate over democracy. The progressive model sees wealth redistribution as a democratic obligation. The conservative model sees it as a democratic violation of property rights.
Democrats frame Republican tax policies as “corporate giveaways,” while Republicans say taxation is government confiscation masquerading as public service.
National Identity and Democratic Sovereignty
Online discussion also uses democracy in immigration debates, though in vastly different ways.
- Democrats argue welcoming migrants is a democratic moral responsibility.
- Republicans say open borders dilute national sovereignty and voter integrity.
- Independents are frustrated with both parties, though a majority support tighter border control.
Because progressives view democracy as inclusive and global, they see strict immigration enforcement as authoritarian. Because conservatives view democracy as national and citizen-driven, they see open-border policies as undemocratic.
The Media and Narrative Control
Public discourse itself is now a contested space. Democrats say “disinformation” threatens democracy and must be fought against. Republicans argue censoring or suppressing speech threatens democracy and freedom.
Social media policies, deplatforming decisions, and mainstream media narratives are becoming battles over who gets to define what “democracy” allows.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)