Justice Samuel Alito was secretly recorded talking about the discontented nature of American politics and partisan divides. During the interaction, Justice Alito said, “One side or the other is going to win. There can be a way of working, a way of living together peacefully, but it’s difficult, you know, because there are differences on fundamental things that really can’t be compromised."

What Americans are Saying

MIG Reports analyzed voter sentiment on the themes Justice Alito spoke about across varying online conversations to determine if voters agree with his position. While reactions to Alito’s comments themselves are scattered and indirect, the themes he spoke about are prominent.

The state of political divides in the country and increasingly irreconcilable value clashes are at the forefront of American discourse. Most people agree that ideological, political, and cultural differences have dwindling prospects for national unity or resolution.

Analysis indicates a clear sense of worry Americans have about the future of the country’s institutions, event beyond government institutions. There are concerns about the erosion of educational institutions, corporations and small business brands, and cultural institutions like the news media and entertainment.

However, there are stark disagreements on the causes and solutions to these concerns. Alito's comments speak to the broader political polarization present in America and real-time voter discussions seem to substantiate his position.

• Discussion topics in three top categories for online conversation demonstrate the accuracy of Justice Alito’s statements about the fracturing of American political and cultural unity.

Ideologies in America

Discussion Trends

• Wokeness: Many people express negative views on wokeness, criticizing it for promoting political correctness, cancel culture, and societal sensitivity. Critics argue it leads to societal decay and stifles free speech.
• Role of Government: There is significant disagreement over government initiatives, with some criticizing perceived overreach and authoritarianism. Opinions are split between support for libertarian or conservative policies versus socialist or liberal measures.
• Identity Politics: Discussions on race, gender, and sexual orientation show defensiveness and hostility towards changing societal norms with little room for compromise.
• Political Partisanship: The division between conservatives and liberals is clear, with each side blaming the other for societal issues and accusing each other of spreading propaganda. There is a yearning for a return to “normalcy,” despite skepticism that normalcy is possible.
• Media Bias: Many believe mainstream media is biased, promoting a leftist agenda or lacking impartiality.

Sentiment Trends

• Society feels upheaval from changing values or oppressive norms.
• Both sides are frustrated and fearful, longing for unity but failing to see a path to it.
• Disagreements hinder understanding, leading to confrontational discourse.

President

Discussion Trends

• Political Focus: Many Americans are discussing political affairs, particularly focusing on President Biden's administration, impeachment efforts, political lies, and border-related issues.
• Polarization: There is a clear divide in discussions between those who support President Biden and those who are against his presidency.
• Accusations and Defense: While both sides engage in accusations and defense, there is also distrust towards the actions and decisions taken by Biden's administration. Some accuse leaders of lying, and others question their motives.
• Lack of Constructive Dialogue: Discussions lack constructive dialogue, with participants engaging in personal attacks and derogatory statements. This contributes to further discord and division rather than seeking solutions.

Sentiment Trends

• There is a prevailing sentiment of disagreement and frustration with the current political landscape.
• Voters express resentment and dissatisfaction towards politicians, accusing them of inaction, political bias, and crimes.
• Sentiments are polarized between those who support President Biden and those who oppose his presidency.
• Overall, there is a sentiment of division and discord, and Americans fear a lack of compromise and peaceful coexistence.

Weaponized Government

Discussion Trends

• Government Criticism: There is much talk about government overreach. Voters express concern about losing control of the government and the growing power disparity.
• Political Party Division: Discussions are marked by a clear divide in political party preferences. Both Democrats and Republicans receive blame for the nation's issues, reflecting deep partisan divides.
• Calls for Citizen Action: Many people emphasize the need for citizens to reclaim government control. There is a strong emphasis on protecting democratic principles and citizen rights.
• Government Involvement in Specific Issues: People discuss federal government involvement in issues like birth control. Discussions highlight the need for a clear delineation of roles between state and federal governments.

Sentiment Trends

• There is a prevailing sentiment of dissatisfaction with the current political landscape and government actions.
• Sentiments are polarized along party lines, with both sides blaming each other for societal problems.
• There’s a strong sensitivity to political partisanship and mutual distrust.
• Many people feel an urgency for the American people to take action on their beliefs.
• There is a call for a proper balance between state and federal government roles.