Papal Infallibility Does Not Include U.S. Immigration Policy
May 25, 2024_.png)
Key Takeaways
- The Pope’s recent open-border comments receive support from typically non-religious liberals and the Catholic Church’s leadership, but many Americans reacted negatively to his comments.
- Many Americans are dismissive of or upset with the Pope’s comments that the U.S. should “open the doors to migration,” which echo similar sentiments in 2016.
- Voters are unlikely to agree with the Pope’s suggestions for U.S. border policy, specifically given the real-world effect of open borders on American communities.
Our Methodology
Demographics
All Voters
Sample Size
2,000
Geographical Breakdown
National
Time Period
2 Days
MIG Reports leverages EyesOver technology, employing Advanced AI for precise analysis. This ensures unparalleled precision, setting a new standard. Find out more about the unique data pull for this article.
Pope Francis recently made several statements regarding the U.S. border and immigration policies. He emphasized the importance of compassion, solidarity, and treating migrants and refugees humanely. His comments highlighted the moral obligations of Christians to support those in need and he advocated for more lenient immigration policies.
The Pope’s overall stance on the current state of the U.S.-Mexico border is to, “Open the doors to migration.” He also commented, “For an immigration policy to be good, it must have four things: for the migrant to be received, assisted, promoted and integrated. This is what is most important, to integrate them into the new life."
Reactions from American Voters
The American public appears to be sharply divided over the Pope's statements. On one hand, liberal and progressive groups tend to support his compassionate stance, viewing it as a necessary call to action for humane immigration reforms. On the other hand, conservative groups criticize his comments, arguing they undermine national security and the rule of law.
Discussions on social media platforms show a clear polarization. Hashtags such as #SupportThePope and #SecureTheBorder reflect the ongoing debate. There's a notable trend of emotionally charged language, with supporters lauding the Pope's moral leadership and detractors accusing him of political interference.
_.png)
Reactions Among Christians
Evangelical Christians
There are some prominent evangelical leaders – particularly those aligned with progressive values – who appreciate the Pope’s stance. But a substantial faction of protestant Christians aligns more closely with conservative and America First sentiments, emphasizing border security and legal immigration processes.
The reaction within evangelical circles often correlates strongly with political ideology. Evangelicals who support more conservative political figures, like Donald Trump, are more likely to criticize the Pope’s statements.
Reactions Among Catholics
Catholic Community
Many Catholic leaders and organizations like the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), have long advocated for comprehensive immigration reform and humane treatment for migrants.
Support for the Pope is particularly strong among the clergy, who often preach about social justice and the moral teachings of the Church. Among the laity, despite broad support for adherence to dogma, some conservative Catholics express concerns similar to conservative evangelicals. They focus on the rule of law and national security.
Opinions can be difficult to parse according to religious membership. However, most Americans recognize significant problems with the state of the border and Biden’s immigration policies. These include impact on American's economic success, loss of values and culture, increasing crime and property crime, and feeling deprioritized by taxes spent to support migrants.
Child trafficking remains a critical issue directly linked to illegal immigration and the current state of the border. Approximately 67%, or around $120,000,000 of USCCB’s grant money year-to-date for the fiscal year comes from Dept of Health and Human Services. HHS administers the Unaccompanied Child Program, which it admits has lost track of at least 35% of the children it processes.
_.png)
_.png)
The Pope’s Previous Statements and the Future
In 2016, Pope Francis made similar statements about the U.S. border, calling for compassion and criticizing the idea of a border wall. Reactions then were similarly polarized, with significant support from liberal and progressive circles and criticism from conservative factions.
Given the historical context and today’s political climate, it is likely any future statements by the Pope on this issue will continue polarize Americans – both politically and religiously. The entrenched political ideologies and the highly charged atmosphere around immigration in the U.S. suggest call for border solutions that can be interpreted as politicized will be met with both fervent support and staunch opposition.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)