Rep. Jamaal Bowman losing the Democratic primary in New York's 16th Congressional District is sparking reactions from both Democrats and Republicans. Bowman, a prominent progressive and member of "The Squad," was defeated by centrist George Latimer 58% to 42%. The race drew intense debate and substantial external financial influence, particularly from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC).

Democrats Are Still Split on Israel

Among Democrats, reactions are deeply split, reflecting the party's broader ideological divisions. Progressive Democrats view Bowman's loss as an example of how significant amounts of outside spending, particularly from pro-Israel groups, can sway electoral outcomes. This group expresses negativity at the idea of financial support for Latimer coming from pro-Israel factions of the Democratic Party.

For these leftists, Bowman's defeat is a casualty of broader geopolitical and ideological battles the party is facing over Israel and Palestine. Many far-left progressives say Bowman's defeat was caused by redistricting and suppressing critical voices for Palestine.

Centrist Democrats tend to interpret Bowman's defeat as a corrective course for the party. They affirm the need for candidates who can resonate more closely with their constituencies, especially on Israel. These Democrats view Latimer's victory as a confirmation of moderate values which more closely reflect the district’s voters.

They assert Bowman's defeat was not solely about financial disparity but about his failure to resonate with his district’s demographic, which includes a significant Jewish population who feel alienated by his anti-Israel rhetoric. They suggest his inability to support even widely accepted legislative initiatives like the historic infrastructure bill further isolated him from a broader constituency.

Complaints Against Bowman

Republicans, meanwhile, are enjoying Bowman’s loss and a political hit for The Squad. There is ample scorn and a sense of vindication on the right, largely directed at Bowman and AOC. Many Republicans are taking the opportunity to condemn Bowman and his progressive allies, calling them extremists who are out of touch with mainstream American values.

Despite an endorsement from one of The Squad’s most well-known members, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Bowman was still unable to secure a win. Some are also criticizing Bowman for a strange outburst during his concession speech.

👀This is from Jamaal Bowman's concession speech broadcast on US national networks - I cannot imagine how this 9/11 truther and prolific lying lunatic lost 😬

📺 @jamqueen1 https://t.co/3aPbaW2T5s pic.twitter.com/PoUpec4uB5

— Ron M. (@Jewtastic) June 26, 2024

For the right, this result is also an indictment of the progressive wing’s stance on the Israel-Palestine conflict. They view The Squad as Hamas terrorist sympathizers and antagonistic towards Israel and Western values.

Bowman’s infamous incident of pulling a fire alarm during a congressional session is also repeatedly brought up. Republicans reiterate their belief that Bowman pulled the alarm to stop a vote and, despite pleading guilty, didn’t face a severe enough consequence. Many revisit the event as proof of his unfitness for office.

Cringey AOC Endorsement

Among Republicans and pro-Israel Americans, there is a palpable sense of satisfaction with Bowman's loss. There are many memes and much derision at AOC's role in Bowman's campaign—especially a rally where she attempted to hype the crowd to a Cardi B song.

Fox News is big mad that we’re for the many, not the money.

We rallied 1200 people in the Bronx to take on dark money, get fired up, and send busloads of volunteers to canvass and phone bank.

It’s called organizing. And it’s fun as hell.

Get into it: https://t.co/KhvvokqBG6 https://t.co/xJpJIi2HhM pic.twitter.com/bBx3HhjsLH

— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) June 24, 2024

Republicans are seizing the moment to not only celebrate Bowman's downfall but to mock AOC, who many view as incompetent and ignorant. They present as a cringeworthy symbol of the Democratic social justice movement they vehemently oppose.

There are many mocking comments about AOC’s failure to help Bowman secure the primary and laughter at her endorsement video.

This video is 1,000,000x more satisfying to watch after Bowman's 20-point loss pic.twitter.com/3UXUNfvJnT

— End Wokeness (@EndWokeness) June 26, 2024

The gloating tone among Republicans extends to calls for further electoral defeats of other progressive politicians. There is a strain of hope that Bowman's loss is the beginning of a wider trend against The Squad.